Determining the Predominant Materials for Triboelectric Nanogenerator Fabrication: A Bibliometric and a Systematic Analysis
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.56294/dm2025764Keywords:
Triboelectric nanogenerator, material selection, bibliometric analysis, energy harvesting, co-occurrence networkAbstract
Introduction: Triboelectric Nanogenerators (TENGs) have gained considerable attention as efficient energy-harvesting devices based on the triboelectric effect and electrostatic induction. Their performance is highly dependent on the materials used, which influence charged generation efficiency, durability, and application potential. Despite significant advancements in material design, a comprehensive analysis of the most frequently used materials and their impact on output performance remains limited.
Methods: A bibliometric and systematic review was conducted to identify the predominant materials in TENG fabrication. Data was collected from Scopus and Web of Science, analyzing publication trends, material co-occurrence, and performance metrics. A co-occurrence network analysis was performed using VOSviewer, and experimental studies were systematically reviewed to evaluate the correlation between material selection and output voltage (Voc).
Results: The analysis revealed that PTFE, FEP, PVDF, PDMS, and carbon-based nanomaterials are the most frequently utilized materials due to their high triboelectric polarity and electrical stability. The highest reported Voc values exceeded 400 V, with hybrid materials, nanostructured interfaces, and electrode engineering significantly enhancing TENG performance. Additionally, China, the United States, and South Korea were identified as the leading contributors to TENG research.
Conclusions: This study quantitatively assesses TENG material trends and their impact on electrical performance. The findings offer valuable insights for researchers and engineers working on next-generation TENGs, facilitating the optimization of material selection for self-powered devices and large-scale energy harvesting applications.
References
1. Li D, Ruan L, Sun J, Wu C, Yan Z, Lin J, et al. Facile growth of aluminum oxide thin film by chemical liquid deposition and its application in devices. Nanotechnol Rev. 2020 Sep 10;9(1):876–85.
2. Guerra J, Collaguazo G. Development of Low-Cost Triboelectric Nanogenerators for Rural Communities in Ecuador. In 2024. p. 45–53.
3. Collaguazo G, Guerra J, Guatemal W. Electric generation from hydraulic fluctuations using piezoelectric ceramics. In: 2022 IEEE Sixth Ecuador Technical Chapters Meeting (ETCM). IEEE; 2022. p. 1–5.
4. Akram W, Chen Q, Xia G, Fang J. A review of single electrode triboelectric nanogenerators. Nano Energy. 2023 Feb;106:108043.
5. Liu H, Yan F, Jin Y, Liu W, Chen H, Kong F. Hydrodynamic and Energy Capture Properties of a Cylindrical Triboelectric Nanogenerator for Ocean Buoy. Applied Sciences. 2021 Mar 30;11(7):3076.
6. Liu S, Liu X, Zhou G, Qin F, Jing M, Li L, et al. A high-efficiency bioinspired photoelectric-electromechanical integrated nanogenerator. Nat Commun. 2020 Dec 2;11(1):6158.
7. Li D, Ruan L, Sun J, Wu C, Yan Z, Lin J, et al. Facile growth of aluminum oxide thin film by chemical liquid deposition and its application in devices. Nanotechnol Rev. 2020 Sep 10;9(1):876–85.
8. Tan J, Fan Z, Sun S, Xu M, Jiang D. A Periodic Wetting Surface Driven by Triboelectric Nanogenerator for Efficient Postimpact Droplet Collection. Adv Mater Interfaces. 2023 Jan 20;10(2).
9. Phogaat R, Yepuri V. Performance enhancement of triboelectric nanogenerator using iodine doped PVDF. Nanosystems: Physics, Chemistry, Mathematics. 2023 Feb 28;14(1):69–73.
10. Liu H, Yan F, Jin Y, Liu W, Chen H, Kong F. Hydrodynamic and Energy Capture Properties of a Cylindrical Triboelectric Nanogenerator for Ocean Buoy. Applied Sciences. 2021 Mar 30;11(7):3076.
11. Liu S, Liu X, Zhou G, Qin F, Jing M, Li L, et al. A high-efficiency bioinspired photoelectric-electromechanical integrated nanogenerator. Nat Commun. 2020 Dec 2;11(1):6158.
12. Li D, Ruan L, Sun J, Wu C, Yan Z, Lin J, et al. Facile growth of aluminum oxide thin film by chemical liquid deposition and its application in devices. Nanotechnol Rev. 2020 Sep 10;9(1):876–85.
13. La M, Choi JH, Choi JY, Hwang TY, Kang J, Choi D. Development of the Triboelectric Nanogenerator Using a Metal-to-Metal Imprinting Process for Improved Electrical Output. Micromachines (Basel). 2018 Oct 27;9(11):551.
14. Yang B, Yao C, Yu Y, Li Z, Wang X. Nature Degradable, Flexible, and Transparent Conductive Substrates from Green and Earth-Abundant Materials. Sci Rep. 2017 Jul 10;7(1):4936.
15. Kim D, Lee HM, Choi YK. Large-sized sandpaper coated with solution-processed aluminum for a triboelectric nanogenerator with reliable durability. RSC Adv. 2017;7(1):137–44.
16. Yang R, Qin Y, Li C, Dai L, Wang ZL. Characteristics of output voltage and current of integrated nanogenerators. Appl Phys Lett. 2009 Jan 12;94(2).
17. Cheng G, Lin Z, Du Z, Wang ZL. Increase Output Energy and Operation Frequency of a Triboelectric Nanogenerator by Two Grounded Electrodes Approach. Adv Funct Mater. 2014 May 22;24(19):2892–8.
18. Liu H, Yan F, Jin Y, Liu W, Chen H, Kong F. Hydrodynamic and Energy Capture Properties of a Cylindrical Triboelectric Nanogenerator for Ocean Buoy. Applied Sciences. 2021 Mar 30;11(7):3076.
19. Chung J, Yong H, Moon H, Duong Q Van, Choi ST, Kim D, et al. Hand‐Driven Gyroscopic Hybrid Nanogenerator for Recharging Portable Devices. Advanced Science. 2018 Nov 27;5(11).
20. Chen T, Shi Q, Li K, Yang Z, Liu H, Sun L, et al. Investigation of Position Sensing and Energy Harvesting of a Flexible Triboelectric Touch Pad. Nanomaterials. 2018 Aug 13;8(8):613.
21. Ahmed A, Hassan I, Ibn-Mohammed T, Mostafa H, Reaney IM, Koh LSC, et al. Environmental life cycle assessment and techno-economic analysis of triboelectric nanogenerators. Energy Environ Sci. 2017;10(3):653–71.
22. Bian Y, Jiang T, Xiao T, Gong W, Cao X, Wang Z, et al. Triboelectric Nanogenerator Tree for Harvesting Wind Energy and Illuminating in Subway Tunnel. Adv Mater Technol. 2018 Mar 10;3(3).
23. Yu A, Chen X, Wang R, Liu J, Luo J, Chen L, et al. Triboelectric Nanogenerator as a Self-Powered Communication Unit for Processing and Transmitting Information. ACS Nano. 2016 Apr 26;10(4):3944–50.
24. Xiong Y, Wang Y, Zhang J, Zheng L, Liu Y, Jiao H, et al. Endowing TENGs with sequential logic. Device. 2024 Oct;2(10):100472.
25. Xu Z, Chang Y, Zhu Z. A Triboelectric Nanogenerator Based on Bamboo Leaf for Biomechanical Energy Harvesting and Self-Powered Touch Sensing. Electronics (Basel). 2024 Feb 15;13(4):766.
26. Liang Q, Yan X, Gu Y, Zhang K, Liang M, Lu S, et al. Highly transparent triboelectric nanogenerator for harvesting water-related energy reinforced by antireflection coating. Sci Rep. 2015 Mar 13;5(1):9080.
27. Zheng L, Lin ZH, Cheng G, Wu W, Wen X, Lee S, et al. Silicon-based hybrid cell for harvesting solar energy and raindrop electrostatic energy. Nano Energy. 2014 Oct;9:291–300.
28. Yang P, Shi Y, Tao X, Liu Z, Dong X, Wang ZL, et al. Radical anion transfer during contact electrification and its compensation for charge loss in triboelectric nanogenerator. Matter. 2023 Apr;6(4):1295–311.
29. Cui N, Wu W, Zhao Y, Bai S, Meng L, Qin Y, et al. Magnetic Force Driven Nanogenerators as a Noncontact Energy Harvester and Sensor. Nano Lett. 2012 Jul 11;12(7):3701–5.
30. Du X, Zhang H, Cao H, Hao Z, Nakashima T, Tanaka Y, et al. Double-Swing Spring Origami Triboelectric Nanogenerators for Self-Powered Ocean Monitoring. Energies (Basel). 2024 Jun 17;17(12):2981.
31. Xu T, Ye J, Tan J. Unravelling the Ageing Effects of PDMS‐Based Triboelectric Nanogenerators. Adv Mater Interfaces. 2024 Jul 21;11(19).
32. Luo J, Lu W, Jang D, Zhang Q, Meng W, Wells A, et al. Millifluidic Nanogenerator Lab‐on‐a‐Chip Device for Blood Electrical Conductivity Monitoring at Low Frequency. Advanced Materials. 2024 Aug 6;36(32).
33. Rotary Triboelectric Nanogenerators as a Wind Energy Harvester. International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering. 2019 Sep 5;8(2S7):321–7.
34. Li L, Zhang J, Wang M, Zhang J, Zeng XF, Wang JX, et al. Electrospun hydrolyzed collagen from tanned leather shavings for bio-triboelectric nanogenerators. Mater Adv. 2022;3(12):5080–6.
35. Mallineni SSK, Dong Y, Behlow H, Rao AM, Podila R. A Wireless Triboelectric Nanogenerator. Adv Energy Mater. 2018 Apr 4;8(10).
36. Yao C, Hernandez A, Yu Y, Cai Z, Wang X. Triboelectric nanogenerators and power-boards from cellulose nanofibrils and recycled materials. Nano Energy. 2016 Dec;30:103–8.
37. Mathew AA, Shanmugasundaram V. Single-Electrode Triboelectric Nanogenerator Device Framework for Wrist Pulse Signal (Nadi) Analysis and Disease Detection. IEEE Access. 2024;12:93531–45.
38. Jannesari M, Ejehi F, English NJ, Mohammadpour R, Akhavan O, Shams S. Triggering triboelectric nanogenerator antibacterial Activities: Effect of charge polarity and host material correlation. Chemical Engineering Journal. 2024 Apr;486:150036.
39. Ajani Lakmini Jayarathna JA, Hajra S, Panda S, Chamanehpour E, Sulania I, Singh Goyat M, et al. Exploring potential of MXenes in smart sensing and energy harvesting. Mater Lett. 2024 May;363:136252.
40. Jannesari M, Ejehi F, English NJ, Mohammadpour R, Akhavan O, Shams S. Triggering triboelectric nanogenerator antibacterial Activities: Effect of charge polarity and host material correlation. Chemical Engineering Journal. 2024 Apr;486:150036.
41. Li K, Han L, Zhang J, Cheng J. Metal‐Organic Framework Derived Multidimensional Carbon/Multifluorination Epoxy Nanocomposite with Electromagnetic Wave Absorption, Environmentally Adaptive, and Blue Energy Harvesting. Small Struct. 2023 Nov 23;4(11).
42. Vafaiee M, Ejehi F, Mohammadpour R. CNT-PDMS foams as self-powered humidity sensors based on triboelectric nanogenerators driven by finger tapping. Sci Rep. 2023 Jan 7;13(1):370.
43. Luo H, Du J, Yang P, Shi Y, Liu Z, Yang D, et al. Human–Machine Interaction via Dual Modes of Voice and Gesture Enabled by Triboelectric Nanogenerator and Machine Learning. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces. 2023 Apr 5;15(13):17009–18.
44. Gao Y, Li Z, Xu B, Li M, Jiang C, Guan X, et al. Scalable core–spun coating yarn-based triboelectric nanogenerators with hierarchical structure for wearable energy harvesting and sensing via continuous manufacturing. Nano Energy. 2022 Jan;91:106672.
45. Zhu J, Wang A, Hu H, Zhu H. Hybrid Electromagnetic and Triboelectric Nanogenerators with Multi-Impact for Wideband Frequency Energy Harvesting. Energies (Basel). 2017 Dec 1;10(12):2024.
46. Zhai C, Chou X, He J, Song L, Zhang Z, Wen T, et al. An electrostatic discharge based needle-to-needle booster for dramatic performance enhancement of triboelectric nanogenerators. Appl Energy. 2018 Dec;231:1346–53.
47. Wang J, Wu C, Dai Y, Zhao Z, Wang A, Zhang T, et al. Achieving ultrahigh triboelectric charge density for efficient energy harvesting. Nat Commun. 2017 Jul 20;8(1):88.
48. Wen Z, Yeh MH, Guo H, Wang J, Zi Y, Xu W, et al. Self-powered textile for wearable electronics by hybridizing fiber-shaped nanogenerators, solar cells, and supercapacitors. Sci Adv. 2016 Oct 7;2(10).
49. Xia X, Zi Y. Heat‐Excitation‐Based Triboelectric Charge Promotion Strategy. Advanced Science. 2024 Nov 14;11(41).
50. Bagchi B, Datta P, Fernandez CS, Gupta P, Jaufuraully S, David AL, et al. Flexible triboelectric nanogenerators using transparent copper nanowire electrodes: energy harvesting, sensing human activities and material recognition. Mater Horiz. 2023;10(8):3124–34.
51. Nguyen TH, Ahn KK. The Effect of a Magnetic Field on Solid–Liquid Contact Electrification for Streaming Flow Energy Harvesting. Energies (Basel). 2023 Jun 18;16(12):4779.
52. Liu C, Shimane R, Deng M. Operator-Based Triboelectric Nanogenerator Power Management and Output Voltage Control. Micromachines (Basel). 2024 Aug 31;15(9):1114.
53. Shen F, Zhang Q, Guo H, Cao C, Gong Y, Wang J, et al. Investigation of Power Density Amplification in Stacked Triboelectric Nanogenerators. ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL MATERIALS. 2024 Sep 22;7(5).
54. Ahmed A, Hassan I, Song P, Gamaleldin M, Radhi A, Panwar N, et al. Self-adaptive Bioinspired Hummingbird-wing Stimulated Triboelectric Nanogenerators. Sci Rep. 2017 Dec 7;7(1):17143.
55. Guo H, Pu X, Chen J, Meng Y, Yeh MH, Liu G, et al. A highly sensitive, self-powered triboelectric auditory sensor for social robotics and hearing aids. Sci Robot. 2018 Jul 25;3(20).
56. Li X, Tao J, Zhu J, Pan C. A nanowire based triboelectric nanogenerator for harvesting water wave energy and its applications. APL Mater. 2017 Jul 1;5(7).
57. Jiang T, Tang W, Chen X, Bao Han C, Lin L, Zi Y, et al. Figures‐of‐Merit for Rolling‐Friction‐Based Triboelectric Nanogenerators. Adv Mater Technol. 2016 Apr 6;1(1).
58. Nan Y, Wang X, Xu H, Zhou H, Sun Y, Wang M, et al. Submerged and completely open solid–liquid triboelectric nanogenerator for water wave energy harvesting. InfoMat. 2024 Oct 14;
59. Lakshakoti B, Sankar PR, Supraja P, Navaneeth M, Mahesh V, Kumar KU, et al. Innovative triboelectric nanogenerator (TENG) design utilizing a stress ball for energy harvesting, wellness, and safety applications. Engineering Research Express. 2024 Mar 1;6(1):015081.
60. Zhou J, Ma X, Gao J, Kim E, Deng Z, Rao Q, et al. Switchable Power Generation in Triboelectric Nanogenerator Toward Chip‐Less Wearable Power Module Applications. Small. 2024 Aug 12;20(31).
61. Liu J, Li S, Yang M, Wang Y, Cui N, Gu L. Coaxial Spring-Like Stretchable Triboelectric Nanogenerator Toward Personal Healthcare Monitoring. Front Bioeng Biotechnol. 2022 Apr 13;10.
62. Choi YS, Jing Q, Datta A, Boughey C, Kar-Narayan S. A triboelectric generator based on self-poled Nylon-11 nanowires fabricated by gas-flow assisted template wetting. Energy Environ Sci. 2017;10(10):2180–9.
63. Qiu Y, Yang D, Li B, Shao S, Hu L. Wearable triboelectric nanogenerators based on hybridized triboelectric modes for harvesting mechanical energy. RSC Adv. 2018;8(46):26243–50.
64. Chen J, Zhang C, Xuan W, Yu L, Dong S, Xie Y, et al. Triboelectric Nanogenerator-Based Self-Powered Resonant Sensor for Non-Destructive Defect Detection. Sensors. 2019 Jul 24;19(15):3262.
65. Chen H, Xu Y, Zhang J, Wu W, Song G. Self-Powered Flexible Blood Oxygen Monitoring System Based on a Triboelectric Nanogenerator. Nanomaterials. 2019 May 21;9(5):778.
66. Sun JG, Yang TN, Kuo IS, Wu JM, Wang CY, Chen LJ. A leaf-molded transparent triboelectric nanogenerator for smart multifunctional applications. Nano Energy. 2017 Feb;32:180–6.
67. Kim MK, Kim MS, Kwon HB, Jo SE, Kim YJ. Wearable triboelectric nanogenerator using a plasma-etched PDMS–CNT composite for a physical activity sensor. RSC Adv. 2017;7(76):48368–73.
68. Mao Y, Geng D, Liang E, Wang X. Single-electrode triboelectric nanogenerator for scavenging friction energy from rolling tires. Nano Energy. 2015 Jul;15:227–34.
69. Hou SX, Maitland GC, Trusler JPM. Measurement and modeling of the phase behavior of the (carbon dioxide+water) mixture at temperatures from 298.15K to 448.15K. J Supercrit Fluids. 2013 Jan;73:87–96.
70. Zhu G, Wang AC, Liu Y, Zhou Y, Wang ZL. Functional Electrical Stimulation by Nanogenerator with 58 V Output Voltage. Nano Lett. 2012 Jun 13;12(6):3086–90.
71. Yang R. A multifunctional triboelectric nanogenerator based on PDMS/MXene for bio-mechanical energy harvesting and volleyball training monitoring. Heliyon. 2024 Jun;10(11):e32361.
72. Xu T, Ye J, Tan J. Unravelling the Ageing Effects of PDMS‐Based Triboelectric Nanogenerators. Adv Mater Interfaces. 2024 Jul 21;11(19).
73. Tofel P, Částková K, Říha D, Sobola D, Papež N, Kaštyl J, et al. Triboelectric Response of Electrospun Stratified PVDF and PA Structures. Nanomaterials. 2022 Jan 22;12(3):349.
74. Leon RT, Sherrell PC, Šutka A, Ellis A V. Decoupling piezoelectric and triboelectric signals from PENGs using the fast fourier transform. Nano Energy. 2023 Jun;110:108445.
75. Song J, Yang B, Zeng W, Peng Z, Lin S, Li J, et al. Highly Flexible, Large‐Area, and Facile Textile‐Based Hybrid Nanogenerator with Cascaded Piezoelectric and Triboelectric Units for Mechanical Energy Harvesting. Adv Mater Technol. 2018 Jun 14;3(6).
76. Chen S, Tao X, Zeng W, Yang B, Shang S. Quantifying Energy Harvested from Contact‐Mode Hybrid Nanogenerators with Cascaded Piezoelectric and Triboelectric Units. Adv Energy Mater. 2017 Mar 18;7(5).
77. Niranjana VS, Yoon JU, Woo I, Gajula P, Bae JW, Prabu AA. Exploring a New Class of PVDF/3‐Aminopropyltriethoxysilane (core) and 2,2‐Bis(hydroxymethyl)butyric Acid (monomer)‐Based Hyperbranched Polyester Hybrid Fibers by Electrospinning Technique for Enhancing Triboelectric Performance. Adv Sustain Syst. 2024 Nov 10;8(11).
78. Mubarak A, Sarsembayev B, Serik Y, Onabek A, Kappassov Z, Bakenov Z, et al. Quenched PVDF / PMMA Porous Matrix for Triboelectric Energy Harvesting and Sensing. ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL MATERIALS. 2025 Jan;8(1).
79. Huang T, Lu M, Yu H, Zhang Q, Wang H, Zhu M. Enhanced Power Output of a Triboelectric Nanogenerator Composed of Electrospun Nanofiber Mats Doped with Graphene Oxide. Sci Rep. 2015 Sep 21;5(1):13942.
80. Izadpanahi A, Azin R, Osfouri S, Malakooti R. Production optimization in a fractured carbonate reservoir with high producing GOR. Energy Geoscience. 2024 Oct;5(4):100334.
81. Ning C, Xiang S, Sun X, Zhao X, Wei C, Li L, et al. Highly stretchable kirigami-patterned nanofiber-based nanogenerators for harvesting human motion energy to power wearable electronics. Materials Futures. 2024 Jun 1;3(2):025101.
82. Garcia C, Trendafilova I. Real-time diagnosis of small energy impacts using a triboelectric nanosensor. Sens Actuators A Phys. 2019 Jun;291:196–203.
83. Lapčinskis L, Ma̅lnieks K, Linarts A, Blu̅ms J, Šmits K, Järvekülg M, et al. Hybrid Tribo-Piezo-Electric Nanogenerator with Unprecedented Performance Based on Ferroelectric Composite Contacting Layers. ACS Appl Energy Mater. 2019 Jun 24;2(6):4027–32.
84. Paosangthong W, Wagih M, Torah R, Beeby S. Textile Manufacturing Compatible Triboelectric Nanogenerator with Alternating Positive and Negative Woven Structure. In: The 3rd International Conference on the Challenges, Opportunities, Innovations and Applications in Electronic Textiles. Basel Switzerland: MDPI; 2022. p. 19.
85. Le TH, Mai UKG, Huynh DP, Nguyen HT, Luu AT, Bui VT. Surfactant-free GO-PLA nanocomposite with honeycomb patterned surface for high power antagonistic bio-triboelectric nanogenerator. Journal of Science: Advanced Materials and Devices. 2022 Mar;7(1):100392.
86. Meng L, Yang Y, Liu S, Wang S, Zhang T, Guo X. Energy Storage Triboelectric Nanogenerator Based on Ratchet Mechanism for Random Ocean Energy Harvesting. ACS Omega. 2023 Jan 10;8(1):1362–8.
87. Geng F, Huo X. A Self-Powered Sport Sensor Based on Triboelectric Nanogenerator for Fosbury Flop Training. J Sens. 2022 Aug 31;2022:1–10.
88. Jiang C, Lai CL, Xu B, So MY, Li Z. Fabric-rebound triboelectric nanogenerators with loops and layered structures for energy harvesting and intelligent wireless monitoring of human motions. Nano Energy. 2022 Mar;93:106807.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Julio Guerra , Isabel Quinde , Gerardo Collaguazo , Andrés Martínez , Germán León (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The article is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. Unless otherwise stated, associated published material is distributed under the same licence.
